ValuePenguin collected millions of car insurance quotes from 39 companies across the U.S. to find auto insurance quotes for the cheapest companies, states and drivers with issues on their records. Average car insurance prices are based on quotes from all available ZIP codes in the U.S. Quotes are for a 30-year-old man who owns a 2015 Honda , Compare car insurance from 120+ companies in our quoting tool, including GEICO, Allstate, Progressive. Save up to $1,025 in minutes with no spam., 2. Get an insurance quote online. Nationwide's auto insurance quote tool is your fastest path to a quick car insurance quote. Enter your ZIP Code and click Get a Quote. Then answer some questions about yourself, the car you want to insure and the people who will be driving the vehicle. You can also get fast car insurance quotes by calling 1-877 , , , .