Shoofly pie has made its way into community and church cookbooks around the country. This old-fashioned, "desperation pie" recipe couldn't be easier to make., Shoofly pie is a classic Pennsylvania Dutch treat that’s packed with old-fashioned charm. The pie is known for its deep, rich molasses filling that is balanced by a buttery cinnamon-spiked crumble topping., It’s a simple deep-dish pie with a filling made with molasses, brown sugar, and eggs. Plus, we added Lyle’s Golden Syrup – which really helps mellow the sometimes-bitter molasses although it isn’t a totally traditional ingredient., Good Shoofly Pie has a wet bottom and tender, molasses kissed crumbs. It is said that Shoofly Pie got its name because its sweet aroma while cooling on the window sill attracts flies. If you find yourself in that situation, wave your hands over the pie and yell, “Shoo fly, shoo”!, Shoofly pie is a traditional Pennsylvania Dutch dessert primarily made with molasses and brown sugar. This combination makes the pie intensely sweet, sticky, and ooey-gooey, almost like caramel. It’s perfect for all the sweet tooths in your life. Some say that shoofly pie was a cheaper version of the treacle tart., .